In the midst of the turmoil and angst that was the 8-5 2011 Texas football season, several amusing things happened.
First, Texas ended up putting together a relatively gratifying turnaround season. 8-5 is nothing to crow about as the second winningest program in CFB history, but it sure as hell beats 5-7 and getting laughed at by every other program in the country. Beating the aggies and winding up with scoreboard was a nice touch.
Second, the QB position became so overwhelmingly absurd in all of its drama, changes, confusion and performances that the fanbase was left with an outsized view on just how dire the situation really was. The swings from last spring with “Connor Wood is pressuring Gilbert for time!” or “Gilbert is the man, just give him time!” to this past summer with “McCoy is making his move! Wood is dropping off!” or “Gilbert is the man, just give him time!” to this past football season’s progression from “Gilbert sucks!” to “Gilbert is the man, just give him time!” to “McCoy and Ash will rotate!” to “Both of these guys are awesome!” to “They both suck!” to “Case McCoy should start, he’s Colt’s brother and he beat ATM!” to, finally, “Ash sucks, but he sucks for our team, so, whatever, we’ll take him. Fuck you, Cal, you bunch of clowns.”
That brings us to now, where the general majority of fans seems to have the sentiment that Texas could be a top 10 team in 2012 if only the program had a QB it could rely on throughout the year. My contention is that it does, and that that player is David Ash, and that a 10 win season is not only in the program’s reach, but should be the expectation.

“But I saw him suck out loud for most of the 2011 season!!??!”
We all did. It wasn’t a pretty year for the guy. Statistically there isn’t much to brag about and in terms of actual viewing, things were occasionally pretty ugly. In the end, none of the issues that plagued David Ash for 2011 have to be persistent problems in the next 3 years. The problems and their solutions are as follows.
A) The Speed of the Game
Unlike Garrett Gilbert, who had about every mechanical issue that a QB can have, David Ash wasn’t broken on that front. Mechanically, he overstrided at times, he threw off of his back foot, and he had happy feet for much of his time in the pocket, but those are products of rushing the game. He still threw the ball off of his ear, not from a wind-up like a starting pitcher. He had plenty of moments where he stepped into his pass reasonably well and his step wasn’t effectively a long stride, which was Gilbert’s every move. While he threw off of his back foot too often, Ash also had his moments where he threw very well on the run when he was flushed. In short, his footwork, delivery, and vision didn’t show signs that each would be total projects to correct or that they were already in a state of bad habits that might never be broken.
Where Ash wound up falling completely short was in his decision-making in the pocket and his ball placement with his receivers. Both of these issues relate directly to the speed of the game.
The guy was barely old enough to vote when he started getting snaps in games in front of 100,000+ people. It really shouldn’t be a surprise that he wasn’t mentally prepared for the game. One of the consistent issues that we witnessed all season long was that Ash would attempt to make plays that weren’t there. He saw windows and spaces that he perceived to be available for a throw when in fact there was a defender waiting to close on the ball. Things that the guy got away with in high school simply created some bad habits in his decisionmaking that needed to be broken through adversity. As a high schooler, the guy had a big arm, good mobility (relatively speaking) and he was playing against mediocre competition, so no doubt he carried over some lazy decision-making habits into his freshman year. (Un)luckily, Ash experienced a ton of adversity by way of poor decision-making last season. A great example of this issue was on full display in the early part of the OU game in which he tried to make something out of nothing on a throw that should have never been made and Hurst, the OU defender, took the pass to the house.
Some guys never grow out of the issue that they believe their arm and physical skills can bail them out of anything and take advantage of any tiny window in the passing lanes. Brett Favre got away with this all the way to a Super Bowl title and a future in the HOF. Ryan Mallett often got away with this at Arkansas. It also cost both of those guys repeatedly. Any poster on this board could name 3+ examples of it costing Favre-led teams. The best Mallett example is from the Sugar Bowl vs Ohio State on the last drive. Attempting to throw the ball literally through a defender is never going to end well for the QB. Of course, both of those players have huge arms, so they had enough success to get away with it. The rest of the QBs tend to be mere mortals and the guys who aren’t head cases can have this issue coached out of them. There is no reason to believe that Ash can’t fit into this group. He showed improved decision-making in the Holiday Bowl and that discipline will remain a focus with this staff. On top of that, Ash is going to get the chance to face some of the most diverse playcalling packages in the country on defense in practice each day. Some things are taught through hearing and others through doing. He’ll get hit on both sides.
The other primary issue with the speed of the game for the guy was his ball placement in the passing game. Players move faster, and by a lot. The guy had to come to the realization that he wasn’t in Belton anymore. That’s a light bulb that will go off through repetition and experience. Ash basically threw behind every target he had in the KSU game. That was probably the nadir of his season in terms of throwing the ball, although I haven’t looked at stats and I have no idea if they reflect that. In any event, this is the most basic of QB issues when the QB goes up a level. Working through the tree and understanding where guys are going to be ahead of the ball releasing is something that comes with time and is a given to be learned for someone who is actually getting the reps. The speed of the game is one of the primary reasons why a redshirt year for a QB benefits them more than any other position.
B) Snaps & Repetition
When Ash arrived on campus last spring, he was the 4th string QB, given the impression that he was likely to redshirt. He was also given 4th string reps, which means he received very few compared to what anyone resembling a starter would need. He had an anointed returning starter, a top 100 redshirt freshman, and the sibling of a legend sitting in front of him.
Any human in that situation might reasonably deduce that the following fall would probably not be their time. Is that what Ash did and did that effect his preparation for some of the offseason? I don’t think anyone here knows, but it’s not an unreasonable assumption. Beyond that, even if the guy was prepping mentally like a starter, it couldn’t have done a ton of good for what he’d face, given that he was receiving roughly 5-10% of the snaps all of the way through 7 on 7 work.
Once fall drills rolled around and the season started, Wood had moved on and the staff had decided not to redshirt Ash. They clearly valued his feet and what his skill set could do in a specific package of plays. In reality, given the plays that involved him early, a case can be made that the focus on those packages for Ash as a player might have actually been a hindrance for his overall development. As his reps became more focused and dedicated to the designed package(s) for him heading into the early part of the season, his overall exposure to the offense decreased and he no longer took consistent snaps with the 2nd string O.
There’s also the issue of timing with the receiving corps and in the running game. As a 3rd or 4th stringer, or the package QB, Ash never had an opportunity to get into any kind of rhythm or develop any kind of connection with the starters. It’s one thing to have bad ball placement because the game hasn’t slowed down for the player, it’s another to have no clue how a particular WR is going to get off the line, or how long one TE may hold a block before releasing as opposed to another. Timing effects exchanges in the running game, it affects the efficacy of the play-action game, and effects the accuracy of the passes in the passing game. Each QB will develop a rapport with his WR/TE corps and gain an understanding of who he wants to go to in various situations and who will be where he needs them to be when he’s flushed from the pocket. Ash had zero chances to do any of this with the starters heading into the season. Certainly some of that began to occur as the season wore on, but the overall impact of any of that development ahead of the bowl game practices was minimal.
Another big problem in Ash’s development as a regular QB in the 2011 season was coaching focus. With a problem QB in Gilbert returning and needing a ton of work, and with an inexperienced set of back-ups behind him, the amount of energy and focus Harsin could put into Ash’s development last spring and early fall could only have been fractional. There is only so much time in the day and the expectations were not of Ash becoming the starter. Ash had opportunities to learn in the communal sense with the other QBs and beyond that, what he got in terms of focus was probably by demand or during Harsin’s down time. The amount of older player mentoring experience at QB that Ash received was probably somewhere near zero. That particular issue won’t be changing, but it’s also another reason why the guy remained so raw through last season. Something there would have helped the guy a long a bit as a supplement to the lack of coaching attention.
All of these snaps and repetition problems go away for 2012.
1) Ash is the starter. He knows it, so does everyone else, and he’s expected to be ready mentally and physically every day.
2) He’ll be exposed to the entire offense and he’ll receive the lion’s share of the snaps in every phase of the season from spring drills through the bowl game.
3) Timing with the rest of the skill players will be a given heading into the season and a magnitude shift in the learning curve will be reflected in this area for the program.
4) He’ll get all of the coaching attention and focus that he could have ever dreamed of from this staff. He’s going to be living, eating, and breathing football with the staff and players through the offseason.
C) Injuries & Teammate Experience
Any QB in the country would be put in a bind when it comes to moving the ball if he was playing behind a refurbished, thin OL going through a complete scheme and technique overhaul. That situation is going to be exacerbated when it is coupled with gratuitous injuries throughout the rest of the offensive skill player depth chart. During the season, the offense lost for extended periods: Jaxon Shipley, John Harris, Fozzy Whittaker, Malcolm Brown, and Joe Bergeron. Blaine Irby was constantly playing from behind, health-wise, as a go-to TE as well. At one point in this season, on the road, Davis Ash was asked to show success moving the ball down the field against a top 30 defense with Jeremy Hills in the backfield, and Mike Davis and Miles Onyegbule at WR.
2012 will no doubt have its fair share of injuries for the program as well. That considered, the depth across the board is better, and so is the experience. The bulk of the OL is back, with a set of actual back-ups with talent, and the scheme and technique work will be more of the same for the whole group. Shipley, Davis, Harris, Onyegbule, and the incoming freshmen will all be targets. The TB group will go 3 deep again with top tier talent and two of the players will have spent a full offseason inside the UT workout and conditioning cycle. TE depth will even be more experienced and talented if McFarland is coming along as well as rumored and Grant continues to develop as well.
”But I know what my eyes saw last year! David Ash is not the answer! Connor Brewer should starts!”
People are entitled to believe whatever they’d like. Shellshock at the QB position in the Post-Colt McCoy era is understandable. Garrett Gilbert’s general ineptitude took most people by surprise, much like his father did with various women on the West Coast during his playing career. The fanbase was not ready for the multitude of problems that were unveiled during Gilbert’s sophomore season. Poor footwork, a baseball wind-up, no composure, no leadership, a mediocre arm, and no phenomenal player development from the alleged wizard of QB coaches, Greg Davis. Only one of these issues was corrected heading into 2011 and that wasn’t enough to save the fanbase from what they witnessed. What has been seen cannot be unseen, so cynicism is warranted.
At the same time, Ash is a different player with a different set of problems and answers than Gilbert. This guy has a real chance to be developed, to learn through some adversity, and to be a part of a title-contending program. That isn’t to say that he’ll press for All Big 12 honors in 2012. He also doesn’t need to do so. All he needs to do is be reliable and viable in the passing game. With everything else this program has going for it with coaches, talent, and depth, Ash does not have to win games on his own for Texas. He just needs to be a solid steward of the offense and to control the ball. If he does those things, the experience will likely set him up very well for honors in the future. Likewise, Texas will be set up for honors going into 2013 and 2014 along with him. That considered, Texas should go 10-3 or better in 2012. If they don’t do so, it’s not going to be because of Ash that they don’t.